You may have set the store to display a custom page you created. Check that the Site Group your customer is a member of is allowed to access that Page. Sites > Pages > Allowed Groups.
Related Article: Ch. 043 Creating Pages in Your Sites
Trouble logging in? Simply enter your email address OR username in order to reset your password.
For faster and more reliable delivery, add firstname.lastname@example.org to your trusted senders list in your email software.